Project outcomes​

  • To develop a set of decision-support tools and techno-economic models to guide selection of potential new products for further investigation and develop recommendations for:
  • Further research projects to improve process viability or product characteristics, and/or
  • Possible commercial opportunities for the industry or partners that would lead to development of full business cases.
  • To develop decision support tools and models available to all collaborators on a shared platform for research and development use
  • To set up a Biorefinery Community of Practice to bring together all parties involved in such work in South Africa, with the aim of setting up a “Virtual Institute of Biorefinery Research of South Africa” to further develop the community beyond STEP-Bio.

Focus areas​

  • Value addition to sucrose​​
  • The techno-economics of sugar, ethanol and cogeneration in South African sugar factories​

​​The South African sugarcane industry has identified the critical need to diversify its product base in order to ensure long-term sustainability and the current drive towards the bio economy and bio-based products presents the ideal opportunity for such. However, the very large number of potential products and the challenges of incorporating the production processes within an integrated biorefinery required the development of decision support systems and techno-economic models in order to assess which products would be the most profitable for the industry to produce and guide decision-making in this regard.

 

This project was a collaborative effort between the SMRI, Stellenbosch University, the University of KwaZulu-Natal and the University of Cape Town. Key outputs were a Matlab® model of a sugar factory with ethanol and cogeneration facilities, an Aspen Plus® model of a sugar factory, Aspen Plus® models of integrated sugarcane biorefineries producing chemical products from bagasse, a decision-support to for evaluating the potential of sugarcane-based bio products and studies on the techno-economics of multiple such bio products.

 

Between the various research groups involved in this project, over 40 different products were considered and assessed to differing degrees of detail according to certain screening protocols. Of these, lactic acid, ethanol and citric acid were generally considered to be most promising, with glutamic acid, succinic acid and butane diol ranking lower but still potentially of interest.

 

Arising from this project, briefing notes on the potential for the manufacture of various chemicals from South African sugarcane feed stocks​, such as polylactic acid (PLA), ethanol, ethylene, mono-ethylene glycol and succinic acid, have been written for the industry’s leadership, based on information obtained from STEP-Bio and market information. These documents incorporate assessments of potential market opportunities for such products and enable informed discussions with potential customers.​​​


Steve Davis

Research & Development Manager, SMRI

Annegret Stark

University of KwaZulu-Natal School of Engineering

Prof. Johann Görgens

Department of Process Engineering, Stellenbosch University

Prof. Sue Harrison

University of Cape Town, Centre for Bioprocess Engineering Research

Starzak M and Davis SB (2017). MATLAB® modelling of a sugar mill: model development and validation, Int. Sugar J., 119 (1422), 442-452.

Booysen KC, Foxon KM and Davis SB (2018) The development of a screening tool to identify new products for the South African sugarcane industry. Int. Sugar J. 36-51

Nieder-Heitmann M, Haigh KF and Görgens JF (2018) Process design and economic analysis of a biorefinery co-producing itaconic acid and electricity from sugarcane bagasse and trash lignocelluloses. Bioresource Technology 262: 159-168

Naidoo M, Tai SL and Harrison STL. (2018) Energy requirements for the in-situ recovery of biobutanol via gas stripping. Biochemical Engineering Journal, 139:74-84

Naidoo P, Lokhat D and Stark A (2019) S-BEAT: A preliminary cost estimation method for the sugarcane biorefinery, Int. Sugar J., , 121 (1441): 30-40

Nieder-Heitmann M, K Haigh, JF Görgens (2020). Life cycle assessment and multi-criteria analysis of sugarcane biorefinery scenarios: finding a sustainable solution for the South African sugar industry. Accepted for publication in Journal of Cleaner Production

Nieder-Heitmann M, K Haigh, JF Görgens, J Louw (2020). Economic evaluation and comparison of succinic acid and electricity co-production from sugarcane bagasse and trash lignocelluloses in a biorefinery, using different pretreatment methods: Dilute acid (H2SO4), Alkaline (NaOH), Organosolv, Ammonia Fibre Expansion (AFEX™), Steam explosion (STEX), and Wet oxidation. Biofuels, Bioproducts & Biorefining 14: 55–77.

Nieder-Heitmann M, K Haigh and JF Görgens (2019). Process design and economic evaluation of integrated, multi-product biorefineries for the co-production of bio-energy, succinic acid and polyhydroxybutyrate (PHB) from sugarcane bagasse and trash lignocelluloses. Biofuels, Bioproducts & Biorefining 13(3): 599-617.

Özüdoğru HMR, M Nieder-Heitmann, K Haigh, JF Görgens (2019). Techno-economic Analysis of Product Biorefineries Utilizing Sugarcane lignocelluloses: Xylitol, Citric Acid and Glutamic Acid Scenarios annexed to Sugar Mills with Electricity Co-production. Industrial Crops and Products 133: 259-268.

Nieder-Heitmann M, KF Haigh, JF Görgens (2018). Process design and economic analysis of a biorefinery co-producing itaconic acid and electricity from sugarcane bagasse and trash lignocelluloses. Bioresource Technology 262: 159–168.

Kapanji KK, KF Haigh, JF Görgens (2020). Techno-economic analysis of chemically catalysed lignocellulose biorefineries at a typical sugar mill: Sorbitol or glucaric acid and electricity co-production. Accepted for publication in Bioresource Technology.

Mokomele, Thapelo, da Costa Sousa, Leonardo, Colbert, Abby, Dale, Bruce E., Görgens, Johann F. and Balan, Venkatesh (2022). Coupling AFEX and steam-exploded sugarcane residue pellets with a room temperature CIIII-activation step lowered enzyme dosage requirements for sugar conversion. Chemical Engineering Journal, Volume 446, Part 2, 15 October 2022, 137117

Morakilea, Tumelo, Mandegari, Mohsen, Farzad, Somayeh and Görgens, Johann F (2022). Comparative techno-economic assessment of sugarcane biorefineries producing glutamic acid, levulinic acid and xylitol from sugarcane. Industrial Crops and Products, Volume 184, 15 September 2022, 115053


Starzak M. and Davis S.B. (2015). Mass and energy balance modelling of a sugar mill: A comparison of MATLAB® and Sugars™ simulations. Proc. Andrew van Hook Symp., 22, 42-61 (Mauritius, 24-26 Feb. 2015).

Starzak M. and Davis S.B. (2016). MATLAB® modelling of a sugar mill: model development and validation, Proc S Afr. Sug. Technol. Ass., 89, 517-536.

Thomson WA, Kohler M and Stark A (2017) An economic analysis of the potential bio-polymer industry the case of sugarcane. Proc. S. Afr. Sug. Technol. Ass. 90:411-414

Inyang V, Ramjugernath D and Stark A (2017) Reactive extraction and reactive distillation a new recovery process development for levulinic acid from fermentation broths. Proc. S. Afr. Sug. Technol. Ass. 90:419-422

Haigh KF, Mandegari MA, Farzad S, Petersen A and Görgens JF (2017) Lignocellulose biorefineries as extensions to sugar mills in the green economy. Proc. S. Afr. Sug. Technol. Ass. 90:402-405

Chikava FK, Ramjugernath D and Stark A (2017) Economic recovery of biobutanol – a platform chemical for the sugarcane biorefinery. Proc. S. Afr. Sug. Technol. Ass. 90:415-418

Booysen KC, Foxon KM and Davis SB (2017) The development of a screening tool to identify new products for the South African sugarcane industry, Proc. S. Afr. Sug. Technol. Ass. 90:431-454

Mafunga W, Ferrer S and Stark A (2017) The development of a partial equilibrium economic model of the South African sugar industry in a biorefinery scenario. Proc. S. Afr. Sug. Technol. Ass. 90:406-410

Chikava FK, Ramjugernath D and Stark A (2017) Butanol recovery from fermentation broths – a techno-economic assessment in the South African context. 2nd NAM S&T international training workshop on industrial biotechnology, Harare, 22-24 August 2017

Azim MM, Stark A, Marondedze ET and Martincigh BS (2017) Strategies for the separation of carboxylic acids from fermentation broths. 2nd NAM S&T international training workshop on industrial biotechnology, Harare, 22-24 August 2017

Naidoo M, Tai SL, Johnstone-Robertson M, Harrison STL (2017) By-product inhibition kinetics of the acetone-butanol fermentation and modelling of in-situ separation on ASPEN Plus Presentation. 10th World Congress of Chemical Engineering, Barcelona, 1-5 October 2017

Naidoo, P, Lokhat D and Stark A (2018) S-BEAT – a preliminary cost estimation method for the sugarcane biorefinery, Proc. S Afr. Sug. Technol. Ass. 91:256-274

Marondedze ET, Martincigh BS, Azim MM and Stark A (2018) Development of reactive extractants for the isolation of carboxylic acids. Proc. S. Afr. Sug. Technol. Ass. 91:275-278

Foxon KM and Starzak M (2018) Upgrading the utility plant module for the generic sugar mill model. Proc. S Afr. Sug. Technol. Ass. 91:273-288